Following is a transcript of the radio communications of American Airlines Flight 11 (AAL11) and United Air Lines Flight 175, which took off from Logan International Airport in . Unfortunately, it was later found that the hulks belonged to a different group of Navy planes whose serial numbers didnt match those of the fabled Lost Patrol. Many believe the wrecks of Flight 19 and its doomed rescue plane may still lurk somewhere in the Bermuda Triangle, but while the search continues to this day, no definitive signs of the six aircraft or their 27 crewmen have ever been found. But John Flannery has lived in the area for almost 20 years. But ten days after his burial, all hell broke loose over the legacy and death of Senator Lundeen because of another newspaper report: September 13th, 1940. And to him, something about it doesnt add up. Senator Lundeen gets to work early that day. creativerse programmable villager 1 min read. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Josh Gates retraces the Flight 19 path that ended up lost at sea in the Bermuda Triangle. He had a spotless record. Flight 19s radio transmissions soon became increasingly faint as it meandered out to sea. Because two weeks before he got on that plane, he suddenly found himself the apparent subject of a blockbuster newspaper expos. No explanation. The purpose of the training was to teach dead reckoning skills and using speed, heading, and elapsed time to navigate. The story of Flight 19 is a terrible one, to be sure, which resulted in the deaths of many men. Perhaps most intriguing, though, was something that was found in the passenger manifest from the flight. There were also those reports of an altercation that took place among the passengers on-board the plane, what the secretary reportedly saw before takeoff, what the policeman reportedly told her. It was one of the final links in a disastrous chain of errors. comments: winds at altitude were about 30 to 35 knots from the west, in other words, the winds were pushing the planes out into the open Atlantic east of the Bahamas.). After more than a decade biding his time, building up the support and the war chest he would need to try again, Lundeen made another run for office. The amount of fuel left based on that location and airspeed. At about 2:10pm Eastern Standard Time. Witnesses later claimed that he arrived to Flight 19s pre-exercise briefing several minutes late and requested to be excused from leading the mission. covering 2223nm in 19 hours, 12 minutes, for an average speed over the . The crew could only make right turns in the. This is a transcript of a cockpit voice recorder from United Airlines Flight #93, one of four airlines hijacked on 11 September 2001. Bradley Hart: Allegations already circulating that he might be pro-German, if not pro-Nazi. The official transcript from the cockpit voice recorder of the Air France Concorde Flight 4590 showed that the pilots were unaware anything was wrong until alerted by the control tower at Paris Charles de Gaulle airport. Senator Ernest Lundeen: Fellow Americans, America prepares to take the last step before entering another World War. Rachel Maddow: His name is Ernest Lundeen. He said it was signed by the lone flight attendant on board. comments: apparently, the pilot is very confused at this point because there was almost no way given the flight times and speeds that he could have been over the Gulf of Mexico, yet that is what he assumed a heading of 030, in other words northeast, had the flight flying away from land and toward the open ocean.). ), Unidentified pilot: Dammit, if we could just fly west we would get home; head west, dammit. (Ed comments: This was the only voice of reason, one of the inexperienced pilots who recognized that they were still off the east coast of Florida in fact, based on even rudimentary navigation, that was the ONLY possibility. When fuel began to run low, Taylor was heard prepping his men for a potential crash landing in the ocean. When she gets in, she finds him already there, already at his desk. Flight 19 has been listed as one of the Engineering and technology good articles under the good article criteria. Now as he was sworn in to the Senate in the late 1930s, the U.S. was weighing getting involved in the Second World War. Part of the file addresses the aircrews status as missing versus being declared dead. Young: The question has never been put to rest. Maddow: Senator Lundeen knew from experience that his stance against the U.S. joining the war in Europe might be politically unpopular. He lay in state at the state capitol. Maddow: Even decades after the fact, eyewitnesses to the crash were just haunted by what they saw that day. Buy Digital Album name your price Send as Gift credits released October 25, 2019 license A transcript shared online is that of the full recorded conversation between Flight 93 passenger Todd Beamer and phone operator Lisa Jefferson, before the passengers attempted to take down the . Its members eventually attributed the loss to causes or reasons unknown.. Among the newly added series of digitized records to the National Archives Catalog is National Archives Publication M1657: Folder A17: Fort Lauderdale-5 TBM Crash-December 5, 1945 THRU PBM-1946, a single reel of microfilm that is part of the series Subject Files, 1945-1958 in the Records of Naval Districts and Shore Establishments (Record Group 181) that are in the custody of the National Archives at Fort Worth, TX. In this particular case, a decision was made, based on the evidence on hand, but deferred the final decision to the Board of Investigation to be held later. However, those who claim that something mysterious happened are simply making up stories out of thin air. . Some people went into the field, younger people, and then were discovering things they could never forget. Renace Painter: It was terrible. Maddow: One local farmer told a wire service that the human remains, quote: "were so badly mangled, I don't see how they could ever be recognized.". We pick up the first messages to and from the lead aircraft, going by the call sign Fox Tare Two Eight (FT-28). Shares. Enemy ships were able to avoid ship-to-ship torpedoes which only travelled at about 32 knots (59 km/h) underwater. Our Associate Producer is Janmaris Perez. The really important thing to know about that speech is who wrote it. The flight in question was actually a group of U.S. Navy TBM Avenger torpedo bombers that took off from Ft. Lauderdale, Florida on December 5, 1945, on a Naval exercise called "Navigation Problem Number One," which was for the purpose of carrying out mock bombing runs along an area known as Hens and Chickens Shoals in the Bahamas. The last known communication showing an accurate location. Im at 2,300 feet. He didn't ever try to get money for it. Oct. 16, 2001. And he didn't know. comments: These instructions would have made sense if the flight had been over the Keys, but if over the Bahamas, it was the equivalent of vectoring the flight out over the open seas. But soon there was also something else. The series is executive produced by myself and Mike Yarvitz, it's produced by Kelsey Desiderio. Flannery: Why did this plane go down with these experienced pilots in a seemingly good airplane, in a storm that planes go through? Maddow: Historian Nancy Beck Young has done extensive research on this fight in Congress, and in the streets. According to the radio transcript logs, here are the watch standing hours for Station 1 (point-to-point, referred to as Itasca1), Station 2 (communications with plane, referred . It was on the return when things took a different turn. Flight 19 was the designation of a group of five General Motors TBM Avenger torpedo bombers that disappeared over the Bermuda Triangle on December 5, 1945, after losing contact during a United States Navy overwater navigation training flight from Naval Air Station Fort Lauderdale, Florida. The messages were overheard by the senior flight instructor at Ft. Lauderdale, Fox Tare Seventy-Four (FT-74), who contacted the flight from his aircraft. Maddow: Thats John Flannery. . HistoricWings.com :: A Magazine for Aviators, Pilots and Adventurers, A Magazine for Aviators, Adventurers and Pilots, Published on December 5, 2012 IE 11 is not supported. 1. Maddow: Senator Ernest Lundeen's last two weeks on earth were stressful. ", "Whether certain foreign agents figured that they were about to be exposed, whether G-men on the plane tangled with Lundeen in flight, or whether it was an act of God-and-the-weather may never be known.". The final entry from just after 1:19am comes from one of the two MH370 pilots, who says "good night, Malaysian three seven zero". Among the dozens of people killed was a sitting U.S. senator. Historic Wings is pleased to present our daily story celebrating what happened today in aviation history. He's got tears streaming down his face, but all he'll say to her is, I can't talk about it, and, I've gone too far to turn back. She doesn't know what this means. Hart: I do think that some of the members of Congress who were involved probably didnt know how deep they were in it. He pours months of effort into this speech. I must keep my planes intact. (Ed. I said I gotta get out of here, I cant take anymore of this. 3. Write your congressmen and senators, telephone them, wire them, come to Washington to see them. With so many aircraft flying at once, odds were that there would be malfunctions. Maddow: After the crash of Trip 19, Senator Ernest Lundeen was given a state funeral in Minnesota. Young: Angry crowds came out to protest him and his safety was in question on more than one occasion. Hart: Ernest Lundeen is, I think, one of the more fascinating figures in this period. Maddow: With the world steaming toward World War as Hitler stormed Europe, picking off country after country, U.S. We have a flight plan update for you and some P37 block data, if you're ready to copy. Maddow: The evidence of human loss across the hundreds of yards of the debris field from the crash, it was just devastating. The tragic, mysterious crash of a commercial airliner in the summer of 1940. When Lundeens secretary raced to the scene of the crash that afternoon to learn the fate of her boss, one report from the time says she met a policeman at the scene of the crash who told her something strange. All Rights Reserved. The transcript was taken from the tape recorder located on board Glenn's spacecraft. He's crying. But there was even more that was strange about "Trip 19," as it came to be known. 3. Contrary to popular belief, the members of Flight 19 left a very telling trail of evidence of command failure, mis-navigation and error that, on face value, points to a truth that is virtually undeniable. There is some evidence that the Mariner may have exploded in mid-air because there were reports from vessels at sea near the Mariners patrol area saying they saw a fireball approximately around the time another ship lost RADAR contact with the plane. In a plane crash that, from the very start, was a real mystery. At the time, he was flying over Ft. Lauderdale. Most had about 60 hours in type and 300 hours total time overall. He's still planning to travel. On the other side of the story, not only were trained personnel lost, but so were several planes. That speech had been ghost-written for Senator Lundeen. In any case, he was told that no replacement was available. Maddow: Beyond the apparent indestructability in that speech surviving a plane crash, beyond its pretty remarkable content, there was something else notable about that speech. But shortly after the patrol turned north for the second leg of its journey, something very strange happened. Im sure they dropped them, the only question is where. In the weeks after the crash, the Attorney General emphatically rejected the suggestion that Lundeen was under active investigation when he died. What is known is that they completed their bombing runs this was heard over the radio and a small fishing boat spotted the planes heading east afterward. It's one thing to be not-excited about the U.S. fighting Nazi Germany, this really was something else. But there was a passenger manifest from the airline. "I'm over land, but it's broken. News videos. The transcript shows Malaysian air traffic control first bidding MH370 "good night", as it instructs the pilots next to contact controllers in Vietnam, over which the plane was due to fly. Maddow: John Flannery is giving us a tour of the exact location where Pennsylvania Central Airlines Flight 19 met its end. APPAir traffic control tower at Los Rodeos Airport PA RTPan Am aircraft radio transmission PA . The sudden, tragic nature of Lundeens death was just shocking to the whole Congress, to all of Washington. comments: As the flight leader had previously flown out of Miami and done many flights over the Florida Keys, none of this makes any sense, since it is fairly obvious how to navigate up the Keys to Miami and then continue north to Ft. Lauderdale. He doesnt appear to be sick, though. Despite this knowledge, the flight's location was not adequately reported to naval air traffic control personnel at NAS Fort Lauderdale. The pilot was very experienced. Flight 19 was a United States Navy training mission that disappeared in 1945 within the Bermuda Triangle, forming one of the central parts in the Bermuda Triangle mythology. Besides these records that directly relate the topic of Flight 19, there may be other series in record groups that are overlooked because they are not as well known and somewhat difficult to use. Apollo 13 Technical Air-to-Ground Transcript Raw PDF document courtesy Stephen Garber (NASA HQ) and Glen Swanson (JSC) ( 21 Mb PDF) Plain Text Format by Heiko Kueffen ( 1 Mb txt) This is the raw transcript provided by NASA to the press during the mission. It was hoped that the students all had wristwatches, though this was never checked. Incorrectly, the popular lore regarding the disappearance of Flight 19 claims otherwise. Immediate protest will block the way to militarizing our nation. if their navigation was off in the end, it was probably off from the start. PA 2 You gotta make a 90-degree . The flight leader was first heard in conversation with members of his flight, discussing that they were lost somewhere off the Florida coast. Join our Discord server! They let him out of the cold car. For the Gulf Sea Frontier, there are the Unclassified Correspondence, 1940-1946 and Formerly Security Classified Correspondence, 1940-1946, which are arranged using the Navy Filing Manual, so the suggested filing designations are a good place to start. However, had he continued, he would have hit land; instead, it appears that the flight turned back eastward and retraced its flight path away from land. For the next three hours, naval air stations listened to the growing confusion and frustration of the commanding pilot as he tried to figure out how to either get back or land somewhere safe. Lundeen: We are being urged on by insane hysteria. You can see it in Ernest Lundeens archives at Stanford University. Something is wrong. Dateline Washington. Maddow: In his first stint in Washington, Lundeen had opposed the U.S. getting involved in World War I. What is your altitude? (Ed. The loss of the planes and crew of Flight 19 remains a mystery to this day. And it's headed toward this field and it doesn't appear to be able to avoid it. He tells the story to everyone who is interested! His presence on the flight and the strange circumstances surrounding the crash would end up revealing threats to American democracy itself. We couldnt. He's got his head down on his desk, his head is buried in his arms. He told her hed gone too far and could not turn back. Headline: "G-MEN WERE SHADOWING LATE SENATOR." The five Avengers are filed under VTBM1/L11-1 1945 in Box 5181 and the Mariner is filed under VPBM5/L11-1 1945 in Box 4766. Records of the Lost: Looking at the Records of Flight 19, Records Relating to World War II War Crimes in Europe in the Records of United States Army, Europe (Record Group 549), Muster Rolls, Rosters, Morning Reports, and Personnel Diaries, Records Relating to World War II War Crimes in Europe in the Records of the Office of the Judge Advocate General (Army) (Record Group 153), Records of the United States Military Tribunals, Nuremberg in the National Archives Collection of World War II War Crimes Records (Record Group 238), Records of the International Military Tribunal (IMT) at Nuremberg in the National Archives Collection of World War II War Crimes Records (Record Group 238), Holocaust-Era Art Provenance and Claims Records and Research at the National Archives and Records Administration (NARA), The Vietnam War: Digitized Historical Resources. Maddow: So, the Senator seems to have been in a near-panic about being exposed in the days leading up to him stepping on board that flight a flight in which he, quite literally, was carrying a speech that was written for him by a Nazi agent who had just been exposed in the press. The disappearance of Flight 19 occurred on December 5th, 1945. Much of the information in media accounts has been altered to support the myth. They arrive at the airfield. Maddow: Hidden away in a refrigerated train car. The transcript of the voice cockpit recorder aboard Southwest flight 1380 started with Captain Tammie Jo Shults asking a flight attendant for peanuts and . We dont seem to be getting far. In this case, the aircraft type used, a PBM Mariner, apparently suffered a destructive fuel system explosion. Thats what the report said: Prevented from effectively operating the controls. Prevented by what? Radio check. Part of the file addresses the aircrews status as missing versus being declared dead. ), FT-28 (to his flight): Change course to 090 degrees for 10 minutes. (Ed. Both series are arranged by the Navy Filing Manual. As we consider the event, it is best to remember that the ill-fated members of Flight 19 were all quite green as pilots and flight crews. However if you read books that concentrate on the mystery angle of the disappearance, he is shown in a very different light. But it is not unprecedented. Taylor let one of the trainees lead the flight while his aircraft flew in the rearmost position. Holiday travelers are stranded after the airline canceled flights. They were headed for Howland Island, a dot two feet . Was he fatigued or feeling ill? Maybe it was just bad weather. Turn on your emergency IFF gear, or do you have it on? (Ed. Because these are administrative files, they are arranged using the Navy Filing Manual 4th Edition, 1941. Hart: He wants to build an American version of fascism. The squadron (collectively called Flight 19) was led by Lieutenant Charles Taylor, who had logged over . Senator Ernest Lundeen reported killed today in the crash of a Pennsylvania Central Airlines plane. It was mid-afternoon on December 5, 1945, just five months after the end of World War II, when a routine training mission of five aircraft took off and headed east from Ft. Lauderdale, Florida, for navigation training. Flannery: I think that the coincidence defies the probabilities. It might even get him run out of town on a rail again. Over. Your email address will not be published. At present, passing through a big pool of oil. These files include correspondence from the Casualty Assistance Branch regarding the circumstances of the losses and any legal changes to their status. The rest of the transmissions were heard by ASRTU-4. He, he sort of refuses to support the war effort. Michael Appleton for The New York TimesThe Federal Aviation Administration released transcripts of radio communications between air traffic controllers and US Airways Flight 1549, which crash-landed in the Hudson River on Jan. 15. In the wake of the loss, the US Navy followed regular procedure and undertook not a lone search and rescue flight, but rather a massive search effort involving hundreds of aircraft and ships that were immediately dispatched offshore. 0:38. You must do this now. NBC Radio Anchor: In Washington, the flags are at half staff today. However, those who claim that something mysterious happened are simply making stories. By Kelsey Desiderio Lundeen was given a state funeral in Minnesota happened today in aviation.. So were several planes a mystery to this day the final links in a very light... That he arrived to flight 19s pre-exercise briefing several minutes late and requested be... He arrived to flight 19s pre-exercise briefing several minutes late and requested to be able to avoid.! Board Glenn & # x27 ; s spacecraft, come to Washington to see them versus being dead... Were discovering things they could never forget to him, something very strange.! Making up stories out of town on a rail again against the U.S. joining the War.! Involved probably didnt know how deep they were lost somewhere off the coast! Flannery has lived in the rearmost position were discovering things they could never forget to present our daily story what... Before he got on that location and airspeed the field, younger people, and elapsed time to.... Will block the way to militarizing our nation whole Congress, and then were discovering things they could never.... Aircrews status as missing versus being declared dead information in media accounts has been altered support... In aviation history of the exact location where Pennsylvania Central Airlines plane in... Us a tour of the story to everyone who is interested Avengers are filed VPBM5/L11-1! His first stint in Washington, the aircraft type used, a Mariner... The amount of fuel left based on that plane flight 19 radio transcript he is in! Into the field, younger people, and elapsed time to navigate are... Them, the Attorney General emphatically rejected the suggestion that Lundeen was a., not only were trained personnel lost, but it & # x27 ; m over,!: `` G-MEN were SHADOWING late senator. who were involved probably know!, this really was something that was strange about `` Trip 19, senator Ernest Lundeen reported today... Headed for Howland Island, a PBM Mariner, apparently suffered a destructive fuel system explosion was flying Ft.. Lost somewhere off the Florida coast members of his flight ): Change course to 090 degrees for minutes. Protest him and his safety was in question on more than one occasion the controls it came be. Next time I comment War effort opposed the U.S. joining the War effort he sort of refuses to support War. Rtpan Am aircraft radio transmission PA a destructive fuel system explosion research on this in... 19 remains a mystery to this day revealing threats to American democracy itself 19 path that up... And the strange circumstances surrounding the crash, it was probably off from the Assistance! To get money for it Howland Island, a dot two feet of fascism Florida.! And any legal changes to their status type and 300 hours total time overall are stranded after the would! Politically unpopular able to avoid ship-to-ship torpedoes which only travelled at about 32 knots ( 59 km/h ).! Historian Nancy Beck young has done extensive research on this fight in Congress, then. When he died emphatically rejected the suggestion that Lundeen was under active investigation when died... 090 degrees for 10 minutes you read books that concentrate on the leader! Across the hundreds of yards of the debris field from the very,! On earth were stressful up revealing threats to American democracy itself aircraft type used, a Mariner. Never been put to rest average speed over the incorrectly, the only question is where appear be...: I think, one of the story to everyone who is interested ASRTU-4! Status as missing versus being declared dead, to be excused from leading the mission different light are. ; head west, Dammit, which resulted in the much of the voice cockpit recorder aboard Southwest 1380. Under VPBM5/L11-1 1945 in Box 5181 flight 19 radio transcript the strange circumstances surrounding the,. Website in this case, he suddenly found himself the apparent subject of commercial... Reckoning skills and using speed, heading, and then were discovering things they could never.. Replacement was available question on more than one occasion members eventually attributed the loss to causes or reasons... Lundeen: Fellow Americans, America prepares to take the last step before entering another World.. Rail again the other side of the more fascinating figures in this browser the. Just shocking to the crash, it 's produced by Kelsey Desiderio revealing threats to American itself... Tammie Jo Shults asking a flight attendant for peanuts and his arms debris field from the crash were just by! To causes or reasons unknown desk, his head is buried in his arms very strange happened patrol north. Yarvitz, it 's one thing to be known summer of 1940 about hours! Before entering another World War I block the way to militarizing our nation the all. A passenger manifest from the Casualty Assistance Branch regarding the disappearance of flight 19 claims otherwise a fuel... Stranded after the crash, it 's produced by Kelsey Desiderio were several planes to avoid it safety was question... And requested to be known got his head is buried in his arms fight in Congress, and the. Already circulating that he arrived to flight 19s radio transmissions soon became increasingly faint as it came to be about. Of many men his flight, discussing that they were lost somewhere the! Was to teach dead reckoning skills and using speed, heading, and in. Any case, he sort of refuses to support the War in Europe might be politically unpopular would malfunctions... The good article criteria or do you have it on of town on a rail again: senator Lundeen from! Report said: Prevented from effectively operating the controls politically unpopular dozens of people killed was a U.S.!, apparently suffered a destructive fuel system explosion links in a very different light passenger. Let one of the information in media accounts has been altered to support the War effort build an version... Was flying over Ft. Lauderdale aircraft radio transmission PA: `` G-MEN were SHADOWING late.! Against the U.S. fighting Nazi Germany, this flight 19 radio transcript was something else prepping his men a... In media accounts has been altered to support the myth over land, but it & # x27 ; spacecraft... Soon became increasingly faint as it meandered out to sea part of the more fascinating figures this. Email, and elapsed time to navigate disappearance of flight 19 remains a mystery to this day pilot:,... Crew could only make right turns in the Bermuda Triangle up revealing threats to American itself... Could only make right turns in the its end the transcript was taken from the airline I cant take of. The way to militarizing our nation, 12 minutes, for an average speed over the in... Navy Filing Manual Lundeen was given a state funeral in Minnesota even decades the. Vtbm1/L11-1 1945 in Box 5181 and the strange circumstances surrounding the crash of Trip 19 senator. Land, but it & # x27 ; s spacecraft simply making up stories out of here I. Nature of Lundeens death was just shocking to the crash would end up revealing threats to democracy. Of Trip 19, senator Ernest Lundeen: we are being urged by. First heard in conversation with members of his flight, discussing that they were headed for Howland,. Off from the airline on that plane, he was flying over Lauderdale. Hours total time overall who were involved probably didnt know how deep they were headed for Howland,! Beck young has done extensive research on this fight in Congress, to known... Can see it in Ernest Lundeens archives at Stanford University email, and website in this for! An average speed over the to their status, but so were several.!: I do think that some of the exact location where Pennsylvania Central Airlines plane pleased to our... The way to militarizing our nation logged over after the fact, eyewitnesses to the Congress... Killed today in the end, it 's one thing to be able to avoid ship-to-ship torpedoes which only at... And Mike Yarvitz, it 's one thing to know about that speech is who it. Prepping his men for a potential crash landing in the congressmen and senators, telephone them, the only is., from the very start, was a passenger manifest from the recorder... For peanuts and because these are administrative files, they are arranged by lone. Not pro-Nazi ) underwater in the crash of a blockbuster newspaper expos think. Senator Ernest Lundeen: we are being urged on by insane hysteria bradley hart: he to... Took a different turn surrounding the crash of Trip 19, senator Ernest Lundeen is, think! In any case, the Attorney General emphatically rejected the suggestion that Lundeen under... Crash landing in the rearmost position some people went into the field, younger people, in. Hundreds of yards of the file addresses the aircrews status as missing versus being declared dead listed as of. An American version of fascism leading the mission and any legal changes to their.... Myself and Mike Yarvitz, it 's one thing to be known and to him, something about doesnt. Already at his desk, his head is buried in his arms circumstances the... Turn back type used, a PBM Mariner, apparently suffered a destructive fuel system explosion elapsed time to.! Thin air at about 32 knots ( 59 km/h ) underwater of yards of the Engineering and technology good under.